We judge concrete changes in control, usable capacity, choice and accountability. Concentration puts greater control in fewer hands or deepens dependence; dispersion gives more people and institutions meaningful capacity to act and challenge decisions. When a development does both, we explain the competing effects.
CONTROL IN FEWER HANDS
Concentration
Control over important capabilities, resources, systems or decisions moves into fewer hands.
Market dominance and government authority
Control of infrastructure and ownership of data
Technical complexity or rules only the largest institutions can satisfy
MORE CAPACITY TO ACT
Dispersion
More people and institutions gain meaningful capacity to act.
Lower costs, wider access and competition
Open standards and shared infrastructure
Stronger public institutions and more accountable systems
02 / THE CENTRAL IDEA
Scale can be necessary. It must remain contestable.
Some technologies require large investments. Some infrastructure must operate at regional, national or global scale. Dispersion does not mean everyone must build and operate everything independently.
Access & alternativesCan others enter the field and gain access to essential resources? Are there meaningful alternatives?
Voice & challengeCan people challenge important decisions and influence how power is used?
Public authorityCan public institutions establish and enforce conditions?
03 / WHERE THE RACE IS RUN
Nine connected arenas.
The lanes give structure without treating developments as isolated. A data center can also be a story about electric rates, water, land-use authority and national strategy.
We assess how concrete actions affect capacity, control, agency and accountability—not AI capability in the abstract.
01
Direction
Does the development move power toward greater concentration or greater dispersion?
02
Contestability
Does it open or close opportunities for competition, public participation and institutional challenge?
03
Real capacity
Does it create meaningful new capacity, or only promise that capacity?
04
Implementation
Are its effects immediate, or will they depend on later implementation?
05
Dependencies
Does a gain in access create a new dependency elsewhere?
06
Connections
Could a development in one lane alter conditions in several others?
A score begins the inquiry. It does not end it.
Concrete developments are recorded when they occur. Implementation may strengthen, weaken or reverse the initial judgment. We distinguish what happened, what it appears to mean, and what could change that reading.
No single event determines the result. Patterns matter more than isolated announcements. The assessment is a structured judgment, not a mechanical index.
Capability and accountability must develop together.
AI will require capable companies, effective governments, substantial infrastructure and technical expertise. Democracy also needs institutions able to understand these systems, enforce rules, provide shared capacity and give people meaningful ways to challenge important decisions.
The question is not whether AI becomes powerful. It is whether that power remains open to challenge, its benefits become broadly usable, and the public retains a meaningful say.