← HomeTHE SCORING APPROACH
How we score concentration and dispersion
A score describes the direction and strength of a concrete change in power: who gains control, who gains usable capacity, and who can challenge important decisions.
Concentration
Greater control moves into fewer hands, or people and institutions become more dependent on those who control important capabilities, resources or decisions.
- Concentration +1Mild / emerging concentration
- An early or partial signal of a change in power.
- Concentration +2Significant concentration
- A clear change in power with meaningful institutional consequence.
- Concentration +3Strong concentration
- A durable, scalable and institutionally important change in power.
Dispersion
More people and institutions gain meaningful capacity to act, make choices, set terms or hold powerful actors accountable.
- Dispersion +1Mild / emerging dispersion
- An early or partial signal of a change in power.
- Dispersion +2Significant dispersion
- A clear change in power with meaningful institutional consequence.
- Dispersion +3Strong dispersion
- A durable, scalable and institutionally important change in power.
0 · Mixed-contested
An important development whose effects are directionally balanced or uncertain. We explain the competing concentration and dispersion effects. Zero is an assessment, not an absence of importance.
No score · Unscored
A development has not yet established a numerical power judgment. It may be a proposal, an announcement, supporting context or a case whose mechanism or effects remain insufficiently clear. A potential direction can be described while the case remains on the Watchlist or in supporting research. No score is distinct from zero.
What earns a score?
We look for meaningful institutional change, adoption, scale, durable capacity, governance consequences, or a material change in public visibility and contestability. The judgment rests on the specific mechanism and its consequences, rather than the size of an announcement alone. Repeated examples do not automatically earn new scores.
The plus sign marks the strength of a change within its named direction. Both Concentration +2 and Dispersion +2 describe significant changes. Scores are structured judgments, not a mechanical index or an overall total.
Window and confidence are separate judgments
The window of contestability asks whether opportunities to enter, influence or challenge a system open, remain available, reopen, narrow or close. Confidence describes the strength and limits of the evidence. We retain implementation conditions, competing effects and observations that could change the assessment.
Events and trends
Event scores assess concrete actions. Trend scores assess a recurring mechanism supported by distinct cases. An unscored trend is not a zero. Individually scored events can provide context for a trend, but their effects are excluded from its numerical scoring evidence. Trend scores are standing assessments; they are not added to event scores or other trend scores.
Browse Events → · Explore Trends →