The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race
← Commentary

ESSAY · THE RACE

Democracy Seems to Be Winning on the Data Center Battles

Communities are using zoning, temporary pauses, enforceable conditions, and financial bargaining to retain public authority over data center development. The emerging democratic gain is meaningful public choice about whether, where, and under what conditions large infrastructure proceeds, even while compute ownership remains concentrated.

Communities across the United States are fighting over data centers. The disputes have become an issue in the midterm elections, as residents question what these projects will mean for their electricity bills, water supplies, public costs, and quality of life. A recurring concern is that communities are being asked to accept developments whose consequences they cannot control.

They often enter these battles seriously outgunned. Developers backed by multinational technology companies bring money, legal representation, and technical expertise that smaller jurisdictions can struggle to match.

But an encouraging pattern is emerging among the cases we track at The Race. Communities are retaining their authority to set meaningful conditions on development and enforce them. This is not yet a nationally established set of practices. It does show how dispersed public institutions can exercise power in the face of concentrated private resources. One of their principal tools is familiar: zoning law.

A familiar democratic tool

Zoning is one way communities express how they want to develop. Cities and counties designate areas for residential, commercial, industrial, and other uses, then establish standards for development within them. Those decisions help shape what a community looks like, how its economy works, and how different uses affect their neighbors.

The rules also give developers advance notice of what is expected. Where the zoning allows it, a project that meets the applicable requirements can receive administrative approval. Other proposals require additional review, public hearings, or governing-body approval under the jurisdiction's rules.

Both routes can serve democratic purposes. Communities establish the standards and decide which proposals warrant individual public review. Developers gain a clearer understanding of the process and the conditions they must meet.

Many communities' existing rules did not anticipate the scale of the data centers now being proposed, along with their demands for electricity, water, infrastructure, and public resources. Updating those rules is a practical exercise of democratic authority.

Create breathing space

A moratorium gives a community time to study those demands and develop appropriate requirements before making commitments that may be difficult to reverse. That can mean revising existing standards, creating a dedicated zoning district, or changing how projects are reviewed.

Some jurisdictions have chosen prohibition. Volusia County, Florida, has banned data centers with an anticipated monthly peak electrical load of at least 50 megawatts in its unincorporated areas. Monterey Park, California, has adopted a citywide prohibition.

Other communities we track have chosen temporary pauses with expiration dates and an explicit purpose of developing rules. On October 22, Clackamas County, Oregon, approved a 120-day moratorium in its unincorporated areas to give staff time to study data center development and appropriate regulations. Two days earlier, Hayward, California, established an initial 45-day pause for impact analysis and consideration of new rules.

A defined period and a clear work program help make a pause reasonable for residents and developers alike. The pause creates an opportunity to govern. What follows determines how much that opportunity is worth.

Establish rules that preserve public judgment

Public involvement matters at two stages: when a community establishes its general rules and when it considers individual projects that require public review.

Tucson, Arizona, illustrates how a community can preserve that second opportunity. Its regulations, adopted August 5, 2026, require neighborhood coordination, a public hearing, Zoning Examiner review, and final consideration by the Mayor and Council for large-scale data center applications. They took effect September 4.

The test is whether people have timely information and a meaningful opportunity to influence the decision. A project may be approved, approved with conditions, or rejected. Residents and developers should understand the standards used and be able to see how the decision was reached.

Clear rules establish obligations. Enforcement gives those obligations practical force.

Make resource demands and costs explicit

The resource questions are straightforward, even when answering them is difficult. How much electricity and water will the full development require? Who will supply them, on what schedule, and with what supporting infrastructure? Who will bear the costs and risks, including effects on existing customers?

Tucson's newly-adopted rules require access to adequate water and power supplies. Nassau County, Florida, is considering draft requirements for electricity supply and infrastructure plans, utility coordination information, and written utility confirmation before each phase begins commercial operations. Its draft also assigns developers the costs of off-site infrastructure and utility improvements necessary for construction. Nassau's requirements remain proposals rather than adopted obligations.

Coweta County, Georgia, provides an example of conditions having consequences. Project Peach received conditional rezoning in 2025 that required a utility service letter, a power purchase agreement, and a land-disturbance permit. After the power purchase agreement and permit requirements were not met, the county voted on October 20, 2026, to return approximately 324 acres to Rural Conservation zoning.

That decision demonstrates the importance of retaining authority after an initial approval. Conditions have limited value if a developer can leave them unmet without consequences.

Reconsider the financial bargain

In several of the cases we track, communities are also challenging the assumption that they must subsidize data centers to secure economic development.

Nassau County's draft would remove data centers from target-industry status and make them ineligible for county economic incentives. In Hermantown, Minnesota, an October 14 city announcement reported that Google would no longer pursue real-property tax abatements. The city and company were also exploring separate support for local schools.

Frederick County, Maryland, offers a particularly revealing example of the value of retaining public authority. A developer offered a package of $110 million in community benefits in exchange for an agreement that would restrict zoning changes affecting its project for eight years. Following public objections, the county executive rejected the agreement application on September 14.

The benefits on offer mattered. So did the public authority the county was being asked to give up. The ability to refuse that bargain is itself evidence of democratic leverage.

These cases show a financial bargain becoming more contestable. They do not establish that subsidies are disappearing across the industry.

Will the gains last?

We are still in the early stages of seeing whether these decisions will produce durable public control. Several tests remain:

  • Will obligations remain enforceable when a project changes owners?
  • Will residents and smaller jurisdictions have timely information and access to technical expertise?
  • Will communities protect shared water supplies and grid customers, or shift costs and risks onto their neighbors?
  • Will the benefits and burdens of development be visible and open to public judgment?

From the perspective of The Race, democracy seems to be winning important battles. Public institutions are converting vocal public opposition into rules, conditions, and enforceable decisions. Communities can then determine openly and fairly whether, where, when, and under what conditions development may proceed.

That is dispersion expressed through public bargaining power and accountability, even while compute ownership remains concentrated. It is what we mean by contestable scale: large infrastructure remaining subject to meaningful public choice. Lasting success will depend on whether those choices hold up in practice.

Published by Mark Howard on The Race. Original wording and supporting source links preserved.

← All commentary