The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race

Watchlist · European Union

EU court adviser distinguishes AI retrieval from model training in a publisher's case

View the linked event assessment →

On November 3, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar issued an opinion in C-250/25, Like Company, involving a Hungarian publisher and Google's Gemini. He explains that online retrieval and reuse can implicate copyright where protected expression is reproduced or made available, including circumvention of effective access restrictions. Facts alone do not receive the same protection as an article's expression. Court's primary explanation ↗.

The opinion also says the training questions should be inadmissible because the necessary factual basis is missing; its alternative discussion generally favors treating training as text-and-data mining. It therefore should not be presented as a blanket holding that training is unlawful. An Advocate General advises the court: the judges have not yet issued a binding judgment.

The power question concerns publishers' practical control over reuse and platforms' exposure to existing copyright remedies. This is exactly the kind of existing-law question that can matter without a new AI statute. Here, however, the body's nonbinding procedural role prevents treating its advice as a final authoritative resolution.

Supporting sources

  1. reuters.com · Source 1 ↗
  2. curia.europa.eu · Source 2 ↗

Source snapshot: 2026-11-03. Individual event and verification dates remain as recorded above. Inclusion alone does not assign a score.