The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race

Policy tool · See record

Structured pre-decision consultation for AI institutional design

What the tool does

Open a defined consultation before deciding AI policy, standards or institutional design. Publish the questions, invite submissions from affected groups and explain how the input was considered in the resulting rules.

Current status

In use through formal public consultation and mandated stakeholder processes. Consultation can influence a decision without transferring final authority. A consultation notice, a completed process and binding rules are different stages.

Where it has been used

San José’s standards consultation

Added by

San José invited community input before completing data-center and large-energy development standards. The process allowed residents to comment while the policy was still being designed. Inviting comments did not itself adopt final obligations or establish that every resident proposal would be accepted.

Read more about this case →

California’s higher-education working group

Added by

Signed AB2392 requires CCC and CSU participation and requests UC participation in a cross-system working group with students, labor, privacy and civil-society representatives. Procurement and training recommendations are due January 1, 2028. Until standards are adopted, systemwide AI contracts require reports within 60 days. A mandated work programme and reporting duty are distinct from delivered training or established procurement standards.

Read more about this case →

California’s protection against fabricated public input

Added by

SB1159 was signed September 30. Public-records, open-meeting, administrative, CEQA and coastal participation rules do not treat autonomous AI or robots as independent persons, and the law prohibits falsely claiming a natural person participated. It expressly preserves human AI assistance at ordinary volume/frequency and disability-related assistive use. It is not a blanket ban on AI-written comments.

Read more about this case →

The Oversight Board’s moderation consultation

Added on

The Oversight Board opened an October 1, 2026 consultation on principles for using large language models in content moderation. Its portal accepted comments in six languages, with a stated October 15 deadline. This was an advisory input process, not an adopted binding rule or a new individual appeal right.

Read more about this case →

ICO’s AI agents consultation

Added on

On October 8, the UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) reported privacy changes secured through its supervision of ten major AI developers: Amazon, Anthropic, Apple, Cohere, DeepSeek, Google, Meta, Microsoft, OpenAI and Stability AI. These are companies developing many models, not ten individual large language models. Some changes are completed; others remain commitments. The work applies existing UK data-protection duties to model training and use, including explaining whose personal data is used, identifying a lawful basis and helping people exercise access and objection rights.

For example, the supervision account documents changes to privacy notices and explanations by Apple, Cohere and OpenAI, and reviews of the justification for using personal data by other developers. On the same day, the ICO opened a public call for evidence on AI agents, which can take actions for users. It closes November 20 and asks about transparency, accountability, security and automated decisions before future guidance and a statutory code. The consultation is open now; the future code is not yet adopted. The underlying data-protection law is compulsory even where firms cooperate without a new enforcement order.

Read more about this case →

BEREC’s internet-openness consultation

Added on

BEREC, the body coordinating European national telecom regulators, adopted a draft report at its October 1–2 meeting and discussed it publicly on October 7. It asks how generative AI changes people's ability to find information, reach services and choose providers. A formal public consultation runs through November 11; non-confidential contributions and a response summary are to be published.

The practical concern is that an assistant may increasingly choose which services a person encounters, while a small number of companies control the models, cloud infrastructure and distribution channels behind it. The report considers whether existing European rules protect openness in those circumstances. It creates an opportunity to influence the analysis; it does not adopt new binding access or interoperability obligations. This defined research consultation does not establish new duties.

Read more about this case →

Pflugerville puts high-risk city technology under elected oversight

Added on

Pflugerville’s council unanimously adopted its SAFE technology policy on October 27. Local reporting distinguishes routine administrative tools, which remain under the city manager, from high-risk systems—including surveillance and biometric identification—that require council review. The identifies RES-1443 as a resolution.

The reported policy preserves human judgment in significant city decisions and generally prevents vendors from selling city data or using it to train general-purpose AI without council approval and legal authorization. A resident commission, public information page and review procedures are to be established within ninety days; they are implementation duties, not demonstrated operating institutions. Specified council authorizations and emergency exceptions matter. The separate November 3 charter proposal should not be confused with this adopted policy.

The resident commission and review arrangements are adopted duties to implement within ninety days, not a completed public consultation or demonstrated operating commission.

Read more about this case →

Ofgem opens consultation on energy-sector AI assurance

Added on

Ofgem opened a formal public consultation on November 18, 2026, concerning proposed AI-assurance guidance for Great Britain's energy sector. Anyone interested can respond by 23:59 on January 15, 2027. Ofgem says it will publish nonconfidential responses and expects to publish its decision and final guidance in March 2027. The questions address evidence that AI used in activities such as forecasting, network planning, pricing and customer service produces safe, reliable, fair and accountable outcomes.

The proposed guidance is voluntary, introduces no new legal requirements, does not displace existing duties and would not constitute regulatory approval of a system. Its earlier June 17 call for input is distinct from the defined consultation now open. The action established today is the outside participation channel before the guidance is finalized, not adoption of the proposed guidance.

Read more about this case →

ACUS opens public input on AI in agency adjudication

Added on

The Administrative Conference of the United States opened a public request for information on November 19, 2026, about generative AI in federal agency adjudication. Parties, representatives, adjudicators and agency personnel can submit experience and recommendations by January 19, 2027, at 10 a.m. Eastern. The Federal Register notice supplies that deadline; the ACUS webpage's reference to 2026 is a typographical inconsistency. Comments normally become public and will inform best-practice recommendations.

Agency adjudication includes decisions on claims or disputes before government bodies. The consultation asks how AI is used by the people deciding and presenting those cases and what safeguards are needed. It creates an operating channel for outside input before recommendations are settled. It does not adopt a binding agency rule, decide an individual case or create a new appeal right.

Read more about this case →

Source snapshot: 2026-11-20. Individual event and verification dates remain as recorded above. Inclusion alone does not assign a score.