The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race

Policy tool · Reusable instrument; FTC United States example

AI claims substantiation and consumer remedies

What the tool does

Consumer authorities can require evidence for representations about AI professional capability, prohibit deceptive service/subscription claims, order monetary redress and notify affected customers. These are specific duties enforceable against covered providers.

Current status

Illustrated by the final January2025 DoNotPay order under existing Section5 authority. It does not impose a general model audit, universal data-minimization rule or establish that all redress was delivered.

Where it has been used

The FTC’s DoNotPay order

Added by

The FTC's January 2025 DoNotPay order prohibits unsupported claims that covered services perform like a human professional. It also prohibits specified misrepresentations about legal analysis, fee savings and subscription features. The order requires $193,000 in monetary relief and notices to eligible customers who subscribed during 2021–23.

These are enforceable duties against a named provider under existing consumer-protection authority. The order requires evidence supporting professional-equivalence claims; it does not impose a general AI-model audit or universal data-minimization regime.

Read more about this case →

Pennsylvania’s AI advertising bill

Added on

Pennsylvania’s House passed Senate Bill 806 on October 7 by 163–40, following the Senate’s June 10 passage by 48–2. The bill would require a clear disclosure when a person knowingly, recklessly or willfully uses AI-generated advertising content to create a false consumer impression about the nature, origin or authenticity of goods or services.

The requirement concerns deceptive synthetic content, with exceptions including text-only material and obviously fictional, satirical or commentary uses. The inspected text provides enforcement through the attorney general or district attorneys, including injunctions and civil penalties of up to $3,000. It would take effect sixty days after enactment. Legislative passage has occurred; the sources reviewed do not establish gubernatorial enactment or current commencement. Bill status and votes; Bill text.

Read more about this case →

The FTC’s impersonation-advertising inquiry

Added on

The Federal Trade Commission’s September 24 advance notice opens a rulemaking inquiry into platforms’ role in promoting advertisements that impersonate businesses or government. It asks whether platforms’ advertising services help scammers reach people and profit from the resulting activity.

The primary notice explicitly discusses AI ad optimization. Potential measures include checking advertisements before publication, detecting and investigating suspected scams, providing reporting tools, removing confirmed impersonation advertisements and stopping optimization services for offending advertisers. The FTC also considers whether such practices might instead form a safe harbor from liability. These are possibilities under consideration, not duties already imposed. FTC announcement.

Read more about this case →

Source snapshot: 2026-10-09. Individual event and verification dates remain as recorded above. Inclusion alone does not assign a score.