Homebase Main Street AI Gap Report
Homebase’s vendor-sponsored survey of 750 owners/operators reports 54% AI adoption below $500,000 revenue versus 81% above $5 million.

Established trend · Active
Latest assessment: · Evidence updated
Smaller firms and workers with fewer training opportunities report shallower access to usable AI than larger or better-supported peers. The likely power mechanism is complementary resources: staff time, skills, suitable workflows and error supervision determine who turns tool access into capability.
Scope: Different selected surveys and qualitative baselines; findings not pooled into a single adoption rate.
Repeated size and learning gaps show that access to AI does not give every organization the same effective capability. The studies do not establish a lasting causal transfer of market share or wages, and some organizations choose not to adopt. Adoption percentages alone cannot resolve the power question.
Homebase’s vendor-sponsored survey of 750 owners/operators reports 54% AI adoption below $500,000 revenue versus 81% above $5 million.
NatWest survey of 1,400 UK businesses reports 67% adoption in firms above 100 employees versus 36% in smaller firms. Proposed Accelerator, Google Cloud and Lancaster support is distinct from the survey results.
PwC survey of 49,364 workers across 48 countries reports unequal access to learning. It measures respondent reports and PwC-defined categories.
San Francisco Fed qualitative analysis separates resource-constrained nonadoption from deliberate decisions not to use AI because of accuracy, IP, human interaction or low usefulness.
Regional employer surveys show AI adoption expanding faster than depth of use; retraining is much more common than reported layoffs.
Later approved evidence — October5: Nonprofit respondent survey describes adoption and resource gaps; anonymous nonprobability sampling limits prevalence claims.
Maryland published an official summary of a June–July survey of nearly 300 business leaders on October 1. It reports 91% using AI,58% basic use and 92% of regular users reporting gains, mostly slight. Sixty-four percent expect existing staff to do more;4% expect headcount reduction.
The full report was blocked, leaving sampling and weighting unknown. These are attributed respondent findings and expectations, not measured productivity or job loss.
Johanna Lara and Claudia Ruiz’s October 5 institutional account describes a June 24 convening of about 100 affiliate staff. UnidosUS’s network comprises roughly 300 community organizations; that is not the number trained at the event.
Affiliates described using AI for notes, intake summaries and reports. At the Latino Economic Development Center, staff began with a list of problems they wanted solved, then built an adoption roadmap rather than selecting a product first. Concerns included privacy, cybersecurity and job security; skeptical staff participated in shaping rollout. The account is participant/organizer evidence. It does not provide a controlled productivity study, verified hours saved across the network, a disclosed programme budget or proof that staff gained formal bargaining rights.
Shared implementation knowledge and community-defined problems can help smaller organizations avoid adopting whatever a supplier happens to offer. Staff participation can improve retained capacity, but differs from an enforceable workplace AI clause.
Justin Holz, Ricardo Perez-Truglia, Andrew Simon and Alejandro Zentner’s August 2026 working paper, NBER 35632, reports a randomized field experiment involving 645 Dallas County households. Both groups received a website with personalized appeal information and supporting evidence; half also received an AI chatbot. 78% of those offered it initiated a conversation. Filing an appeal without a human agent rose from 41.4% to 50.5%, a 9.1-percentage-point increase.
The authors report smaller gains among less-advantaged households and call the evidence of wider disparities suggestive. The authors’ abstract, also indexed at SSRN ↗, supports those findings. The available abstract does not establish recruitment details, subgroup uncertainty or appeal outcomes. These figures establish increased self-filing within this experiment, not successful appeals, reduced tax liabilities, county revenue losses or a population-wide effect.
This is directly about AI-mediated access to a public fiscal/legal process. It illustrates how equally available tools can produce unequal effective capability. Its relevance does not depend on claiming AI has already eroded the property-tax base.
Other fiscal research examines possible tax architecture under AI-driven economic change. This study is a different kind of evidence: measured behavior inside an existing tax-administration process. It is not evidence for the shift toward capturing AI-generated surplus.
Workday’s October 5 report analyzes recruiting activity from over 550 customer employers and a separate September survey of 6,000 workers. Basic AI-skill mentions fell 25% after a January peak while applied automation/engineering demand rose 51% from September 2025 to July 2026. Many respondents know which skills they need, but fewer say employers help them obtain those skills. Recruiting-system data describe participating employers, and worker answers are self-reports; neither represents a measured economy-wide replacement rate. Primary report ↗.
The evidence separates access and training from effective implementation. Participating-employer data and business-contact anecdotes can identify uneven capacity, but do not establish causal job replacement across the economy.
Separately, a St Louis Fed article published July 16 ↗, resurfaced in October distribution, reports May business-contact survey results. Thirty-four percent regularly used AI in a small portion of operations, with 38% of nonusers citing skills/data/technology barriers and 34% seeing no use for AI. Examples include claimed time savings and growth without hiring; these anecdotes are not causal estimates. Almost half expected no headcount change. July publication and May evidence must not be relabeled an October study.
The evidence separates access and training from effective implementation. Participating-employer data and business-contact anecdotes can identify uneven capacity, but do not establish causal job replacement across the economy.
Kansas State University announced October 7 that it had established an AI stewardship committee and adopted an interim framework for reviewing AI uses. Faculty and staff can submit tools through an intake process, allowing the university to assess security, privacy, records and other institutional implications.
The framework follows an April report. Some access is already available, including limited Claude Teams use without institutional data; fuller policies and a registry remain work for 2026–27. The announcement does not establish a completed university-wide AI governance system.
This is more than purchasing access to a chatbot. It begins to retain the knowledge needed to decide which uses are acceptable and how existing institutional responsibilities apply.
Distinct connection: Retained institutional implementation/intake knowledge and practical public capacity. Overlapping evidence is not independent confirmation.
Sector study documents integration, skills and organizational constraints; self-selected consultation is not population or causal evidence.
Official survey patterns distinguish accessible uses from core-workflow integration; related Irish statistics are not independent corroboration.
A union member survey supplies qualified evidence that effective workplace use requires support and organizational learning; no representative adoption or causal productivity estimate.
Pooling firms with common operational problems and reskilling support addresses uneven practical implementation capacity; launch targets are not evaluated gains.
A commercially sponsored survey of 100 federal IT decision-makers reports gaps between agent use, defined authority, human review and staff preparation; self-report is not an agency audit.
Separate survey evidence about uneven organizational preparation; retain the sample, definitions and self-report limitations.
Separate survey evidence about uneven organizational preparation; retain the sample, definitions and self-report limitations.
Separate survey evidence about uneven organizational preparation; retain the sample, definitions and self-report limitations.
Separates tool access or subscriptions from practical implementation and retained organizational knowledge.
Survey compares uptake and implementation barriers by firm scale.
Executive-reported workforce readiness lags adoption; sponsor and self-report limit inference.
Cross-country enterprise and age comparisons document uneven reported use, with differing coverage and no causal market-power finding.
Representative worker-use data and bounded qualitative experiences distinguish actual reported adoption from predicted job effects.
The size gap in adoption and skills barriers among adopters provide survey evidence that access and the ability to implement differ; the survey does not establish concentration.
Spanish survey linked to financial records shows diffusion alongside persistent advantages for existing intensive users.
Unclear for smaller firms and less-supported workers: access differences do not yet establish durable exclusion, and some nonadoption is a rational choice.
Independent long-term outcomes, accessible learning opportunities and retained skills in smaller institutions would help distinguish durable disadvantage from a temporary adoption gap.