The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race

Policy tool · See record

Large-load utility tariffs and cost-allocation rules

What the tool does

Set the electricity prices, financial guarantees and system-upgrade obligations for very large customers. The aim is to make the users creating new costs pay for them, while protecting other customers if demand fails to materialize.

Current status

In use in project-specific arrangements and adopted public frameworks; broader proposals and proceedings remain unsettled. Pennsylvania’s framework is an adopted example. PJM’s Reliability Backstop Procurement remains proceeding-qualified, and the federal Ratepayer Protection Act has not become a uniform current tariff.

Where it has been used

Pennsylvania’s GRID cost protections

Added by

Pennsylvania adopted Executive Order 2026-05 and its GRID framework on August 18, 2026. Developers seeking covered Commonwealth permits, support and tax benefits must meet linked conditions addressing cost responsibility and public impacts. GRID requires developers to bear project-attributable generation, transmission, distribution, interconnection and related infrastructure costs rather than shifting them to existing customers. Access to the existing data-center equipment tax exemption is conditional on meeting the requirements; this is not a new uniform electricity tariff.

Read more about this case →

PJM’s suspended backstop procurement

Added by

FERC/PJM accounts describe acceptance of Reliability Backstop Procurement suspended five months to February 28, 2027, with refund/proceeding conditions. Commissioner statements identify cost-causation and forecast concerns. The full operative order remained unavailable, and procurement did not begin September 30. This is distinct from the existing IRAS proposal.

Read more about this case →

The federal Ratepayer Protection Act

Added by

The US House passed the Ratepayer Protection Act, H.R.9340, but Senate cloture failed 57–43 on September 30, 2026. The proposal would require state or utility consideration of standards for covered large electricity loads, including a 100-megawatt campus threshold. It does not impose a single nationwide protective tariff, and the failed cloture vote left enactment unresolved.

Read more about this case →

Michigan’s attorney general challenges the DTE–Google power agreement

Added on

Michigan’s October 1 order conditionally approves DTE’s Google contracts. Its final provisions require Google’s payments to cover service costs, remove caps on infrastructure-upgrade contributions and place insufficient-collateral risk on DTE rather than protected customers. DTE must expressly accept the conditions within 30 days and file revised contracts where necessary.

A qualification matters: footnote 19 excludes customers who do not pay power-supply costs from the order’s references to protecting “other customers,” and notes staff’s expectation that those choice customers would pay more. The order therefore should not be summarized as a guarantee that every other customer’s costs cannot increase. Order, pages 137–140 and footnote 19.

On October 30, Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel asked the Public Service Commission to reconsider its October 1 conditional approval of DTE’s twenty-year electricity contracts for Google’s Van Buren Township data center. The filed petition seeks stronger protections or rejection of the contracts. It is a challenge to an approval, not a ruling overturning it.

The central dispute is how to count costs and benefits. The commission accepted an assessment over the whole contract term; Nessel wants annual accounting and reconciliation. Her petition quotes the order’s expectation of annual net costs to other customers during 2035–2038, while disputing whether projected benefits in other years adequately protect them. She also seeks fuller transmission-cost accounting and removal of a collateral cap. These are contested prospective costs, not measured charges already imposed on households.

Read more about this case →

Cheyenne’s Google power agreement

Added on

Black Hills announced October 6 that it had signed definitive agreements, effective September 30 and running through 2048, to serve Google's planned Cheyenne, Wyoming, data center. The planned load is 1.8 gigawatts. Black Hills would provide up to 590 megawatts through its utility arrangement and manage roughly 2.1 gigawatts of third-party resources in a private microgrid. This is a combination of utility service and dedicated private infrastructure, rather than a wholly off-grid campus.

The company plans $1.8 billion of investment during 2027–29. Google is advancing $399 million for equipment, refundable by June 30, 2027. Service is expected to begin in late 2027, with load increasing through 2030. Black Hills describes capital recovery, collateral and early-termination protections in the agreements. Those are the company's account of the terms; they do not establish that every generator's output is exclusively Google's. The capacity is planned, not operating.

Read more about this case →

Duke’s proposed large-customer terms

Added on

Duke Energy and several large customers filed a negotiated settlement October 6; Duke announced it October 7. It would establish special electricity-service terms for new or expanded loads of at least 50 megawatts with consistently high utilization, or at least 150 megawatts regardless of utilization. Earlier service arrangements receive substantial protection from retroactive changes.

The proposal requires financial security for infrastructure and long contracts, with minimum durations generally reaching 10 or 15 years depending on project size and ramp-up. Early departure would trigger defined payments, including remaining infrastructure obligations and part of remaining minimum demand charges. The North Carolina Utilities Commission still must approve the settlement. Its proposed January 1, 2027 start is conditional. Environmental advocates dispute whether the protections adequately isolate other customers from costs.

Read more about this case →

Senate passes the permitting bill containing data-center cost provisions

Added on

The Senate passed H.R. 2347, the American Affordability and Jobs Act, 62–33 on November 19, 2026. This is final Senate passage, beyond the earlier substitute and cloture votes. The package combines federal permitting reforms with provisions concerning allocation of costs for large computational loads. It is not law: House agreement and presidential action remain outstanding.

Earlier September text allowed states to go beyond incremental-cost recovery in ways benefiting other customers. The complete comparison of the Senate-passed text with substitute 6883 remains unfinished, so the record does not assert that every original threshold, exemption or public-credit provision survived unchanged. Passage verifies the chamber's action without verifying every detailed cost term or making those terms operative.

Read more about this case →

Indiana’s Monrovia power agreement

Added on

On October 7, Indiana utility regulators approved AES Indiana's arrangements for Google's planned 390-megawatt data-center load near Monrovia in Morgan County. The associated generation and storage project has an estimated $737.3 million cost; the load figure describes planned electricity demand, not an operating campus or the solar plant's capacity. Commission order, case 46394.

The approved structure includes minimum-demand payments, termination provisions and financial assurances. AES describes a minimum 15-year contract and an 80% minimum-demand obligation. The commission retains review of actual costs and their allocation in future rate proceedings. Nevertheless, WFYI reports testimony placing $32.3 million of direct-connection facilities on Google while $73.8 million of network upgrades enter the utility's regulated asset base for recovery through future rates. The order rejects requiring Google to pay every remaining network-asset dollar when its contract ends because those assets can continue serving others. AES's approximately $770 million customer-benefit estimate is a forecast, not realized savings. AES account.

Read more about this case →

The full UK Covenant explains how strategic projects could move ahead in the power queue

Added on

The Treasury's October 28 Covenant document, recovered today, adds detail to the existing case. Strategic projects seeking additional government help must meet its tests; other operators are encouraged to do so. Proposed support includes reserving future grid capacity, reallocating capacity released by departing projects and facilitating transfers of pre-2030 connection contracts. Exceptionally strategic projects could seek temporary on-site power only where other measures cannot secure capacity in time.

The proposed exchange includes community-developed benefit plans tied to project size, annual resource reporting and public-service compute access. The government still has to define strategic eligibility and additional criteria. The document does not establish a universal community payment formula, an already operating priority-allocation process or community enforcement rights.

Read more about this case →

PJM proposes a faster route for paired generation and large demand

Added on

PJM filed its Fast Energization proposal on November 16. Studying new generation and large loads together could halve study time from about two years to one. Flexible interim service could allow earlier connection subject to curtailment; states and utilities would have more visibility into costs. FERC has not approved the terms.

Read more about this case →

California ISO files access and cost rules for large loads

Added on

CAISO filed ER27-532 on November 16 for transmission-connected loads with at least 50 MW peak demand. The proposal addresses deposits, financial security and reimbursement under transmission owner tariffs, disclosure of colocated generation, and possible flexible early service with load reductions. It is a filing, not an operative tariff.

Read more about this case →

MISO files a large-load connection process with upfront safeguards

Added on

MISO's November 16 filings propose a milestone-based study process, agreements with cost and minimum commitments and financial security, and a tracking dashboard. These are separate from its older operating and colocation filings and have not been approved.

Read more about this case →

ISO New England files firm and interruptible pathways for large loads

Added on

ISO New England filed ER27-484 on November 13. Its proposed large-load process differentiates firm and nonfirm service and provides for studies and deposits. Its cost formula is disputed. The filing was recovered through overlap; it is not an approved tariff.

Read more about this case →

Source snapshot: 2026-11-20. Individual event and verification dates remain as recorded above. Inclusion alone does not assign a score.