The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race
← Tools

Practical tools for contestable scale

Governing infrastructure

What tools let public authorities set enforceable terms for AI’s physical footprint?

Impact disclosure, study pauses, integrated review, tariffs, water permits, reliability, and phased approvals.

11 policy tools. Status distinguishes verified use from adopted measures, proposals and ideas.

11 of 11 policy tools match · Showing 11

Policy tool · See record

Tax-expenditure accountability and development-rights value capture

Bucket: Infrastructure Governance Tools / Public Capacity Tools Status: Emerging public tool Primary lanes: Lane 09 — Public Finance and Fiscal Capacity; Lane 03 — Compute and Physical Infrastructure; Lane 01 — Governance and Regulation

Current status: Emerging instruments; proposed and reported examples; operative fiscal terms held

Lanes 1, 3, 5, 6 · Source snapshot: 2026-11-21

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Data-center impact disclosure

Require data-center applicants to explain their expected electricity demand, water use, emissions, noise, land effects and public infrastructure costs before approval. Disclosure gives officials and residents evidence for deciding which conditions a project needs.

Current status: Adopted framework

Lanes 1, 3, 6, 8, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-29

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Temporary moratoria as rulemaking pauses

Temporarily prohibit new approvals while a government studies impacts and writes rules. A binding, time-limited pause can preserve public choices before projects secure development rights. Its scope, exceptions, duration and next steps must be clear.

Current status: In use

Lanes 1, 3, 6, 8, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-11-21

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Large-load utility tariffs and cost-allocation rules

Set the electricity prices, financial guarantees and system-upgrade obligations for very large customers. The aim is to make the users creating new costs pay for them, while protecting other customers if demand fails to materialize.

Current status: In use; terms vary

Lanes 1, 3, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-11-20

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Water-use permitting and water-rights review

Use water permits, water rights and land-use authority to decide whether a data center may draw on a limited water supply. Require a credible supply assessment and enforceable conditions, or prohibit uses that exceed the community’s resource boundary.

Current status: In use; mechanisms differ

Lanes 1, 3, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-23

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Phased approvals for hyperscale projects

Approve a very large project in stages, with later expansion depending on evidence about impacts and compliance. Genuine staged approval gives the public a decision at each consequential expansion, rather than treating a full buildout as inevitable.

Current status: Candidate; binding use not verified

Lanes 1, 3, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-10

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Smooth approvals through ordinary planning

Use ordinary planning rules to assess a project openly, hear objections and issue a reasoned decision. Approval can be democratically contestable when the rules, evidence and review rights are visible; opposition is not the only sign of public control.

Current status: Established process; outcomes vary

Lanes 1, 3, 9 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-30

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · See record

Community participation in AI infrastructure decisions

Give residents a way to influence data-center siting and infrastructure rules through public meetings, submissions, hearings and appeals. Useful participation occurs early enough to affect location, resource demands, conditions or whether approval is granted.

Current status: In use; influence varies

Lanes 1, 6, 8 · Source snapshot: 2026-11-05

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · New York example; local negotiations

Negotiated community-investment agreement

Negotiate developer payments into a locally administered fund for public infrastructure and community priorities, with clear obligations and administration.

Current status: Voluntary model; executed agreement and funded account not verified

Lanes 3, 9, 1, 6 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-15

Read tool and examples →

Policy tool · United States

Land-use prohibitions on large data centers

A land-use prohibition excludes a defined class of data-center development from a specified jurisdiction or area. Unlike a temporary study pause, it establishes a continuing restriction unless changed through lawful procedures. Coverage thresholds, geographic limits, exceptions and existing rights determine its reach.

Current status: See current status

Lanes 3, 1 · Source snapshot: 2026-10-21

Read tool and examples →
Related Specific Events (3)