The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race
← Trends

Established trend · Active

The local data-center bargain is shifting toward an explicit public-return ledger

Latest assessment: · Evidence updated

Standing score
Unscored
Direction of power
Mixed-contested
Window
Unclear
Confidence
Moderate

What we think is happening

Host governments and developers increasingly describe tax preferences together with retained taxes, community payments and public-service commitments. The mechanism is bargaining over the public return to scarce land, power, permission and services, rather than treating headline private investment as the public benefit.

Scope: Selected U.S. fiscal negotiations; approval, proposals and delivery distinguished.

Potential direction of power

Sabey and Brookwood illustrate negotiated packages; Lea and Eagle-type proposals expose unfinished terms, while Mount Pleasant changes incentive flows. Together they show a recurring bargaining practice. Whether it improves public leverage or net fiscal returns depends on the obligations governments secure and the costs they retain.

Supporting cases

AI companies and unions promote Indiana data-center guardrails instead of bans

October 6 Indiana reporting describes the American Infrastructure Alliance’s campaign for uniform rules on energy costs, water and community benefits. Its coalition joins technology/infrastructure interests and construction labor. The Indiana campaign argues that developers should pay their own power costs and accept meaningful standards, while opposing moratoria. The reporting includes Kokomo project and future-revenue claims; those projections are not collected taxes or independently verified net public benefits. Coalition’s own proposals ↗.

This is political bargaining over which constraints development will face. Shared developer-union support can create a governing coalition while narrowing which public demands are considered legitimate. Construction-job support is not an enforceable worker-AI clause, and promised gross revenue is not a net public-return assessment.

Read the case and sources →

Duke proposes stronger terms for North Carolina's largest electricity customers

Duke Energy and several large customers filed a negotiated settlement October 6; Duke announced it October 7. It would establish special electricity-service terms for new or expanded loads of at least 50 megawatts with consistently high utilization, or at least 150 megawatts regardless of utilization. Earlier service arrangements receive substantial protection from retroactive changes.

The proposal requires financial security for infrastructure and long contracts, with minimum durations generally reaching 10 or 15 years depending on project size and ramp-up. Early departure would trigger defined payments, including remaining infrastructure obligations and part of remaining minimum demand charges. The North Carolina Utilities Commission still must approve the settlement. Its proposed January 1, 2027 start is conditional. Environmental advocates dispute whether the protections adequately isolate other customers from costs.

The important mechanism is an enforceable allocation of risks between a very large customer and the wider utility system. A negotiated promise to protect ratepayers becomes meaningful only through the approved accounting, security and exit provisions.

Read the case and sources →

Senators challenge what data-center companies mean by paying their own costs

On October 9, Senators Elizabeth Warren, Richard Blumenthal and Chris Van Hollen released an investigation of seven data-center companies: Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft, CoreWeave, Digital Realty and Equinix. Staff used responses to their December 2025 inquiries and interviews to examine electricity costs, tax preferences, disclosure and employment claims.

The report identifies an important distinction: paying for a company's own substation is different from paying for upgrades elsewhere on the shared electricity network that its demand makes necessary. Staff argue that company promises to pay their full costs can leave those wider costs with other customers. The report also examines confidentiality agreements, equipment-tax exemptions and incomplete accounting of permanent jobs. These are findings from a congressional investigation, not a comprehensive independent measurement of every project's net public costs. Primary report, including the evidence and qualifications ↗.

For The Race, this sharpens the question behind our existing utility and fiscal cases: who defines the costs that a developer must pay, and can the public inspect that definition? It provides evidence for testing bargains such as DTE's conditional protections; it does not establish that every arrangement fails.

Read the case and sources →

Window of contestability

Unclear for host governments over the contract term: final enforceable benefits, tax sacrifices and exit/security terms determine whether choices expand or harden.

What would change this assessment

Executed payment and cost-allocation terms, security against nonpayment, successor obligations and transparent net public-return accounts would show whether negotiation produces a durable public benefit.

Related cases

← All 24 trends