The Race — Building Democracy in the Age of AI. People race toward a shared finish line.
The Race
← Trends

Emerging hypothesis · Active

Communities try to move participation upstream of irreversible buildout

Latest assessment: · Evidence updated

Standing score
Unscored
Direction of power
Undetermined
Window
Opens
Confidence
Low

What we think is happening

Petition campaigns and scheduled hearings seek to create public choice before permits, costs and dependencies harden. The mechanism is timing: ordinary participation tools may be more useful before development becomes difficult to reverse.

Scope: Selected U.S. permitting and organizing cases; a provisional procedural window.

Potential direction of power

Petitions and hearings can give residents a voice before development permissions harden. The remaining examples show opportunities to participate, while their ability to change a final decision remains uncertain. Clackamas has since adopted a moratorium and is linked separately as an individual event.

Supporting cases

Vilas County committee moratorium recommendation

Local reporting describes a September 23 zoning-committee recommendation for a twelve-month data-center moratorium. Multiple local sources corroborate the recommendation, but the official notice and final committee minutes were not available for this account.

The full county board’s decision is expected November 10. No specific proposed campus is established by this record.

Read the case and sources →

Mendocino extends its data-center pause, with a small-project exception

Mendocino supervisors voted 4–1 on October 6 to extend the September 1 data-center pause through August 21, 2028. Reporting describes an exception for facilities using less than 3 megawatts, healthcare exemptions and progress reports every four months. Adoption of permanent regulations can end the pause earlier.

The extension gives staff more time to develop rules before major projects obtain rights. Its long duration also reflects limited planning capacity; elapsed time alone does not demonstrate effective public bargaining.

The extension potentially preserves bargaining time before large projects establish facts on the ground. Its exemptions and the quality of eventual rules determine how much public leverage survives.

Read the case and sources →

San Joaquin pauses new data-center approvals while developing permanent standards

San Joaquin County's board voted unanimously October 6 for a 45-day moratorium on land approvals for new data centers in unincorporated areas. The county announced the action October 7. The pause is intended to give officials time to develop an ordinance governing future projects, following an earlier direction to study their effects.

The relevant concerns include water and electricity demands and the conditions under which the county would approve projects. The action changes the approval timetable; it does not establish a permanent ban or demonstrate that a particular application has been rejected. The adopted measure's precise exemptions and effective period still determine its full reach.

This meets your test that a moratorium should have an identifiable planning purpose. Its potential dispersive effect comes from preserving time and authority to write conditions before development creates irreversible commitments.

Read the case and sources →

Senators challenge what data-center companies mean by paying their own costs

On October 9, Senators Elizabeth Warren, Richard Blumenthal and Chris Van Hollen released an investigation of seven data-center companies: Amazon, Google, Meta, Microsoft, CoreWeave, Digital Realty and Equinix. Staff used responses to their December 2025 inquiries and interviews to examine electricity costs, tax preferences, disclosure and employment claims.

The report identifies an important distinction: paying for a company's own substation is different from paying for upgrades elsewhere on the shared electricity network that its demand makes necessary. Staff argue that company promises to pay their full costs can leave those wider costs with other customers. The report also examines confidentiality agreements, equipment-tax exemptions and incomplete accounting of permanent jobs. These are findings from a congressional investigation, not a comprehensive independent measurement of every project's net public costs. Primary report, including the evidence and qualifications ↗.

For The Race, this sharpens the question behind our existing utility and fiscal cases: who defines the costs that a developer must pay, and can the public inspect that definition? It provides evidence for testing bargains such as DTE's conditional protections; it does not establish that every arrangement fails.

Read the case and sources →

Window of contestability

Opens provisionally for residents before buildout if existing hearings/petitions lead to real choices; qualification and binding outcomes remain unverified.

What would change this assessment

October 3 clerk certificates, Casa Grande result and applicable rules; Clackamas is now scored context; follow remaining institutional triggers separately. Track ballot certification, binding public decision rights or enforceable conditions as distinct institutional triggers. October 5 D1002 case follow-ups are retained with each supporting/context record.

Related cases

← All 24 trends